Litigation in the FinTech Space: An Overview

Litigation in the FinTech space in India has been on the rise in recent years due to the rapid growth and adoption of digital financial services. FinTech refers to the use of technology to provide financial services, and has gained significant momentum in India over the last few years. As the FinTech sector in India continues to grow, it has led to an increase in disputes and legal issues.

In India, the FinTech industry is regulated by various laws and regulations. Some of the key laws related to FinTech in India are:

• Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007: This act governs the payment and settlement systems in India, including electronic funds transfers, credit card transactions, and mobile banking. It provides for regulating and supervising payment and settlement systems in India.
• Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the central bank of India and has been given the power to regulate and supervise the financial system in India. The RBI Act empowers the RBI to issue licenses to FinTech companies and regulate their activities.
• Information Technology Act, 2000: This Act governs electronic commerce, electronic contracts, and digital signatures in India. It provides a legal framework for electronic transactions and creates a legal basis for electronic records. It recognizes electronic records and digital signatures as legally valid and provides for establishment of the Cyber Appellate Tribunal to hear appeals against decisions of the Adjudicating Officer under the Act.
• Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999: This Act governs foreign exchange transactions in India. FinTech companies dealing with cross-border transactions have to comply with the regulations under this Act.
• Companies Act, 2013: This act regulates the formation, functioning, and management of companies in India. FinTech companies operating in India have to comply with the regulations under this act.
• Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India Act, 1999: This act governs the insurance sector in India. FinTech companies offering insurance products have to comply with the regulations under this Act.
• Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992: This act governs the securities market in India. FinTech companies dealing with securities have to comply with the regulations under this Act.

Litigation in FinTech cases in India typically revolves around disputes related to contracts, intellectual property, data protection, fraud, cybercrime, and regulatory compliance. The scope of litigation in FinTech cases in India is vast and involves contractual disputes as FinTech companies often enter into agreements with various stakeholders, including customers, vendors, and service providers, so there may arise a circumstance where one party fails to fulfil its obligations under the agreement. Intellectual property disputes are another area where disputes may arise when another party infringes on the intellectual property rights of the companies, as these companies rely heavily on their intellectual property, including patents, trademarks, and copyrights. Further, data protection and privacy disputes can come up as FinTech companies collect and process vast amounts of personal and financial data. This makes them vulnerable to data breaches and cyber-attacks; hence, disputes may arise when a company is accused of committing fraud or when a company’s systems are hacked, resulting in a loss to the customers. Another major dispute is related to regulatory compliance as it is mandatory for the FinTech companies to comply with various laws and regulations, including those related to banking, securities, and data protection, and disputes arise when a company fails to comply with these laws and regulations.

Thus, the scope of litigation in FinTech cases in India is broad and varied, covering a range of legal. As the FinTech sector in India continues to grow, likely, the number of disputes and legal issues will also increase. Several cases happened in India related to FinTech, some of the notable ones are:

• Abhijit Mishra v. UIDAI & Ors.[1]: In 2020, a petition was filed in the Delhi High Court alleging that Google Pay, another popular digital payment platform in India, was sharing users’ transaction data with third-party vendors without their consent. The case is currently under investigation.
• Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) v. Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Limited[2]: In this case, the SEBI held that the issuance of Optionally Convertible Debentures (OCDs) by Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Limited was in violation of securities regulations. The case highlighted the importance of regulatory compliance in the financial services industry.
• KS Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India[3]: In this landmark judgment, the Supreme Court of India declared the right to privacy as a fundamental right under the Indian Constitution. This judgment has significant implications for the FinTech industry in terms of data protection and privacy regulations.
• Internet and Mobile Association of India (IMAI) v. Reserve Bank of India[4]: In this case, the Supreme Court of India overturned the RBI’s ban on cryptocurrency trading, stating that the RBI did not provide sufficient evidence to justify the ban. The judgment was a significant victory for the cryptocurrency industry in India.
• Future Retail Ltd v. Amazon.com NV Investment Holdings LLC & Ors.[5]: In this case, the Delhi High Court granted an interim injunction against Future Retail Limited’s deal with Reliance Industries, which was challenged by Amazon. The case highlighted the importance of regulatory compliance and contractual obligations in the FinTech industry.

Needless to mention, still FinTech companies in India are facing various legal challenges, including regulatory compliance issues, data privacy concerns, and disputes with customers and partners.

One of the major legal challenges faced by FinTech companies in India is related to regulatory compliance. The RBI is the primary regulator of the country’s banking and financial services industry, and FinTech companies must comply with its guidelines and regulations. Failure to do so can result in penalties, fines, and legal action.

Another area of concern for FinTech companies in India is data privacy. India’s data protection laws are still evolving, and there is no comprehensive legislation governing the collection, use, and storage of personal data by FinTech companies. This has resulted in legal disputes related to data breaches, misuse of personal data, and violation of privacy rights.

FinTech companies in India have also faced legal challenges related to disputes with customers and partners. These include disputes over payment processing, fraud prevention, and transaction disputes. In some cases, these disputes have resulted in legal action, which can be time-consuming and expensive.

Thus, the FinTech industry in India is facing a complex and challenging legal landscape. Companies operating in this space need to be aware of the regulatory and legal requirements and take proactive steps to address compliance and legal risks. This includes investing in robust data privacy and security measures, ensuring transparent and fair customer agreements, and developing effective dispute resolution mechanisms. Nevertheless, the regulatory environment for FinTech in India is evolving rapidly, and new regulations are going to be introduced to keep pace with the changing landscape.

Litigation helps to resolve FinTech cases as it can help FinTech companies resolve disputes with customers or other parties. For instance, if a customer claims that a FinTech company has charged them unfairly, the company can defend itself in court and prove that it has followed all the necessary procedures. FinTech is a rapidly evolving field, and there may be legal issues that are unclear or untested. Litigation can help clarify these issues by setting legal precedents and guiding other FinTech companies. FinTech companies rely heavily on their intellectual property, such as patents, trademarks, and copyrights. Litigation can help these companies protect their intellectual property rights and prevent others from using their technology without permission. These types of companies in India are subject to various regulatory requirements. Litigation can help these companies demonstrate that they comply with these requirements and avoid penalties or fines. Thus, litigation can be a powerful tool for FinTech companies in India to protect their interests, resolve disputes, and navigate the complex legal landscape.

Despite various challenges suffered by FinTech companies in India, they still do not fail to offer the benefits that can be availed by the users. Such advantages include accessibility as these FinTech companies provide financial services through digital platforms, and it is easier for people living in remote areas to access banking services. They are cost-effective as they typically have lower operating costs as compared to traditional financial institutions, thus making it easier for people with lower incomes to access financial services. They are impressively innovative, offering various user-friendly services like mobile wallets, peer-to-peer lending and online investment platforms, thus offering customers more options for managing their finances. As these companies use advanced technology and automated processes to complete transactions through which they are able to process faster transactions, thus, reducing the cost and time associated with manual processes. With the advanced security measures, these companies are able to protect customer data and prevent fraud creating a safer environment for people to use digital financial services in India. Henceforth, FinTech companies have brought greater convenience, efficiency, and affordability to the financial sector and have helped to expand financial inclusion in the country.

Over the years, the Indian government has implemented a number of measures to promote foreign investment in the FinTech industry and streamlined the investment process. In 2016, one of the significant steps was taken to liberalise the Foreign Direct Investment (“FDI”) regime in relation to the financial services sector by the RBI and the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (“DPIIT”), allowing 100% FDI under the automatic route (i.e., without requiring any prior approval from the Indian Government) for the category of “other financial services”. This created a pathway for any organisations providing financial services in India that are subject to regulation by any financial authority to draw in foreign capital. The minimum capitalization standards for “other financial services” operations were subsequently established, even if they were unregulated, for “fund-based” and “non-fund-based” activities, respectively. This move made it possible for FinTech businesses to attract investors from all over the world.

The development of the underlying digital infrastructure that has underpinned the expansion of FinTech over the past ten years has been significantly aided by the government, negating the necessity for private firms to create their own infrastructure. The wide-ranging technological stack that makes up Aadhaar and e-KYC, the universal payments interface and other payment platforms of the National Payments Corporation of India, DigiLocker, eSign, the Open Credit Enablement Network, and the account aggregator architecture are included here.

Additionally, the Indian Government has created a regulatory framework for establishing International Financial Services Centres (“IFSCs”) in India. For the purpose of offering financial services to resident and non-resident participants in a foreign currency (i.e., not the Indian Rupee), IFSCs have been conceptualised as financial services special economic zones with firms established there legally considered foreign corporations. Without having to abide by the foreign exchange rules that would otherwise be in place in India, the IFSC framework enables investors to route capital into India smoothly. More recently, the IFSCA has introduced comprehensive and business-friendly regulations governing capital markets, insurance, and funding vehicles, among others which stand completely equivocal to domestic Indian laws.

In addition, a number of initiatives, including market studies, regulatory sandboxes, innovation programs, incubation, and funding support, have been launched across regulatory domains for the financial, securities, and insurance sectors to enable the testing of new technologically driven products, services, and business models for these markets in a controlled regulatory environment. This has made it possible for business players to take a more active part in  building the regulatory framework for the FinTech sector in India, along with the consultation procedure that authorities in this field often employ prior to the introduction of any new regulations.

Several legitimate policy concerns have been brought up by the growth of the FinTech industry, including those related to data privacy and protection, data monopolisation, cyber security risks, consumer protection against fraud, money laundering, the impact on financial stability, and a broader systemic risk to India’s financial ecosystem. India’s vast underbanked and new-to-bank population makes it the most exciting opportunity place to be in right now. It is now to be seen as to how the FinTech revolution is going to change the habits and behaviour of the Indian population.[6] Nevertheless, litigation has played a role in shaping the regulatory environment for FinTech companies in India, forcing them to become more innovative and attract investment. This has helped in fueling the growth of FinTech companies in India and expand financial inclusion in the country.

In the realm of FinTech cases in India, litigation commonly centers around conflicts concerning agreements, intellectual property, data protection, cybercrime, fraud, and adherence to regulatory standards. FinTech enterprises often enter into contracts with multiple parties, such as customers, vendors, and service providers, thereby opening the door for potential disputes if one party fails to satisfy its obligations. In addition, disputes may arise when another party infringes on a company’s intellectual property rights, as these companies rely heavily on patents, trademarks, and copyrights.

FinTech companies gather and process vast amounts of personal and financial data, making them susceptible to data breaches and cyber-attacks, resulting in potential privacy disputes and accusations of fraud. Regulatory compliance is another major area of contention, with FinTech companies being required to adhere to various laws and regulations related to banking, securities, and data protection. The breadth and diversity of legal matters involved in FinTech cases in India are vast, and as the FinTech sector continues to grow, likely, the number of disputes and legal issues will also increase. There have been several notable cases in India concerning FinTech.

FinTech companies in India are currently confronting a range of legal obstacles, such as issues surrounding regulatory compliance, data privacy, and conflicts with customers and partners. One of the most significant legal hurdles for FinTech companies is ensuring compliance with regulatory guidelines set forth by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), which serves as the primary regulatory body for the country’s banking and financial services industry. Any failure to meet these standards can result in harsh penalties, fines, and legal action. Additionally, data privacy concerns have emerged as a major area of unease for FinTech firms in India, as there is no comprehensive legislation governing personal data collection, utilization, and storage. This lack of clear regulatory guidance has led to legal conflicts pertaining to data breaches, misuse of personal information, and breaches of privacy rights. Lastly, legal disputes arising from payment processing, fraud prevention, and contractual disagreements with customers and partners have presented additional challenges for FinTech companies in India.

The FinTech industry in India is grappling with a multifaceted and formidable legal landscape, encompassing issues such as regulatory compliance, data privacy, and disputes with customers and partners. To mitigate risks, FinTech companies must proactively ensure compliance with regulations, fortify data privacy and security measures, and establish effective dispute resolution mechanisms. Litigation can be a potent tool to protect companies’ interests, resolve disputes, and navigate legal complexities. Despite these challenges, FinTech companies offer substantial benefits to users, including accessibility, cost-effectiveness, innovation, and enhanced security measures. They have also helped to expand financial inclusion in the country by bringing greater convenience, efficiency, and affordability to the financial sector.

References: